Each year St. Nathys College gives recognition to students who have contributed significantly to the overall life of the school in their own unique and particular way.

Such a contribution may lie in any of the following areas:
The school awards nominal non-monitory prizes for successful students.
Even upon consultation with staff and students it is usually extremely difficult to narrow the number of potential recipients of these awards from across the entire student population down to a smaller number. In fact, most students were nominated for some achievement.
Those students nominated most frequently for various outstanding contributions to school life were recently presented with awards. We wish them continued success.
| 6C | O'brien | Darren | Ballaghaderreen |
| 6C | Doherty | Martin | Monasteraden |
| 6C | Puri | Bharti | Ballaghaderreen |
| 6G | Bolton | Patrick | Tavrane |
| 6G | Brennan | John | Glann |
| 6G | Dixon | Liam | Gurteen |
| 6G | Durcan | Kieran | Ballaghaderreen |
| 6G | Grehan | Niamh | Kilmovee |
| 6G | Leetch | Karen | Loughglynn |
| 6G | Madigan | Garbhan | Ballinagare |
| 6G | Mcdonagh | Catriona | Gurteen |
| 6G | Mitchell | Christopher | Frenchpark |
| 6J | Callaghan | Mairead | Kilmovee |
| 6J | Dowd | Mary | Tibohine |
| 6J | Lavin | Danica | Tibohine |
| 6M | Phillips | Sarah | Tibohine |
| 6M | Regan | James | Brusna |
| 6R | Deery | Sandra | Lisacul |
| 6R | Madden | Danielle | Tibohine |
| 6T | Jordan | Owen | Ballaghaderreen |
|
First Year: |
Second Year: |
Third Year: |
|||
| 1C | Aoife Guilfoyle | 2G | Gavin Fitzpatrick | 3C | Chloe Conlon |
| 1P | Peter Cunniffe | 2K | Eimear Dooney | 3D | Bernard Morahan |
| 1T | Eilise Grainger | 2M | Jordan Kennedy | 3D | Derek Rogers |
| 1T | Joseph Harrison | 2R | Kieva Tansey | 3P | Patricia Viana |
|
Fourth Year: |
Leaving Cert: |
||||
| 5H | Declan Quinlan | 6C | Martin Doherty | ||
| 5H | Sarah Coleman | 6G | Paul Healy | ||
| 5M | Katie Gibbons | 6G | Ryan Finn | ||
| 5O | Patrick Morris | 6J | Danica Lavin | ||
| 6J | Siobhan Greevy | ||||
| David Heffernan | (1A) | Dylan Feeney | (1C) | Ann Marie Coleman | (1P) |
| Cathal Madigan | (1A) | Sophie Platt | (1C) | Emma Kilkenny | (1P) |
| Shauna McCoy | (1A) | Lisa McIntyre | (1K) | Christina Barron | (1T) |
| Kelvin Curley | (2A) | Dylan Rushe | (1K) | Niamh Flannery | (1T) |
| Stephen Frain | (2A) | Sarah Moloney | (2K) | Jennifer Kelly | (1T) |
| David OGrady | (2A) | Pooja Puri | (2M) | Colin Dowd | (3D) |
| Ciara Flynn | (2G) | Daniel Giblin | (2R) | Chloe McCoy | (3D) |
| Caroline Morley | (2G) | Jane Maxwell | (2R) | Dhanya Varughese | (3F) |
| Neil Morris | (2G) | Majella Dooney | (3C) | Seamus Cunniffe | (3P) |
| Ciaran Roddy | (2G) | Bharti Puri | (6C) | Chloe Heffernan | (3P) |
| Eimear Dooney | (2K) | Garbhan Madigan | (6G) | ||
| Ailish Egan | (5B) | Mairead Callaghan | (6J) | ||
| Adam Mullen | (5G) | Cherelle Platt-Kenny | (6J) | ||
| Conor Brehony | (5H) | Ian Frain | (LCA2) | ||
| Kevin McDonagh | (5H) | Donia Arafa | (TY) | ||
| Declan Quinlan | (5H) | Anna Deigna | (TY) | ||
| Aisling Towey | (5N) | ||||
| John Murren | (5R) |
| Annie Regan | PRISM Competition | 1st Year Winner 2010/11 |
| Celine McDonald | PRISM Competition | 3rd Year Winner 2010/11 |
| Julieanna Higgins | PRISM Competition | Senior Winner 2010/11 |
| Donnacha Egan | PRISM Competition | Senior Winner 2010/11 |
| Cathal Curley | Irish Debating Success | 2010 /11 |
| Stephen Keegan | Irish Debating Success | 2010 /11 |
| Ashling Phillips | Irish Debating Success | 2010 /11 |
| Garbhan Madigan | Senior Boys Basketball Player of the Year | 2010/11 |
| Emma Hannon | Senior Girls Basketball Player of the Year | 2010/11 |
| Janie Fahey | Outstanding Success in Badminton | 2010/11 |
| James Lafferty | Gaelic Football Player of the Year | 2010/11 1st Year |
| Shehroz Akram | Gaelic Football Player of the Year | 2010/11 2nd Year |
| David Caldwell | Gaelic Football Player of the Year | 2010/11 Juvenile |
| Darren Davey | Gaelic Football Player of the Year | 2010/11 Junior |
| Finbarr Cregg | Gaelic Football Player of the Year | 2010/11 Senior |
| Channon Fahey | Commitment to Student Lifestyle | 2010/11 |
| Ian Freyne (LCA2) | Commitment to Student Lifestyle | 2010/11 |
| Karen Leetch | Extra Curricular Activities | 2010/11 |
| Danica Lavin | Extra Curricular Activities | 2010/11 |
| Patrick Morris | Outstanding Performance in Drama | 2010/11 |
| Wayne Beirne | Outstanding Stage Manager | 2010/11 |
| Ciaran Donoghue | Outstanding Effort Junior Cert | 2010/11 |
| Mary Dowd | Leadership Qualities | 2010/11 |
| Ryan Finn | Leadership Qualities | 2010/11 |
| Mairead Callaghan | 100% School Attendance | 2006 - 2011 |
| Niamh Loftus | Social Awareness | |
| Darren OBrien | Social Awareness | |
| Sarah Phillips | Social Awareness | |
| Martin Doherty | Social Awareness | |
| Patrick Bolton | Hospitality | 2010 |
| John Brennan | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Martin Doherty | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Alison Kerrane | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Patricia Kerrane | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Christopher Mitchell | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Sarah Phillips | Hospitality | 2010 |
| Megan Burke | Outstanding Musical Achievement | 2010/11 |
| James Regan | Commitment, Dedication & Endeavour | 2010/11 |
| Alice Rooney | Commitment, Dedication & Endeavour | 2010/11 |
| Lorraine Regan | Commitment, Dedication & Endeavour | 2010/11 |
| Gerard Regan | Best Team Player LCA2 | Android Tablet |
| Katie Roddy (1C) | Positive Attitude | 2010/11 |
| Keith Rogers (3D) | Positive Attitude | 2010/11 |
| Edel Finn (6J) | Positive Attitude | 2010/11 |
| Bharti Puri | Best Contribution from an International Student | |
| Katie Gibbons | Contribution to Cultural Exchange | 2010/11 |
| Caitriona Quinlan | Contribution to Cultural Exchange | 2010/11 |